“The Middle”
by Jimmy Eat World
from the album Bleed American
2001
Buy the album on Amazon

I’m going for the low-hanging fruit with this selection because Chris and I just discovered how fun it is to do as a duet a few months ago.  What a great tune to switch hit with your friends.  It’s totally easy to pass the stanzas back and forth and then come together on the chorus.  Plus it’s got some fun air guitar moments if you’re into that sort of thing… which I am.  

Chris pogoing on one side of the stage and myself wailing on a non-existent Les Paul on the other.  A crowd favorite.*

*Your mileage may vary.